Is It Wrong To Suck A Cat Girl’s Ear In Another World? – ‘How Not To Summon A Demon Lord’ Episode 1 Review

What’s the show? Hot NOT To Summon A Demon Lord, Episode 1.

And what’s it about? Takuma is a shut-in who is obsessed with the MMORPG ‘Cross Reverie’ so obsessed in fact that he’s the most powerful character in the game, bequeathed the title of Demon Lord Diablo and something of a ‘final boss’ for other players who dare take up arms against him! But one day he wakes up in the fantasy world he loves so much, except he’s not himself in this world but rather has all the physical and power-based attributes of his online avatar, Diablo!

Right… And how did he get into this fantasy world? Ordinarily when it comes to these Isekai shows I’d say something like “don’t be ridiculous they don’t explain the how of these things, it just ‘happens’!” But here it seems he was ‘summoned’ here by busty elf Shera L Greenwood and pantherian (cat girl) Rem Galleu. What the were expecting to summon was an obedient slave, but because of one of Takuma’s—or rather Diablo’s—magical items all spells are countered and returned to the caster, meaning these two girls are his slaves!

Hey, her eyes are up there!

Oh boy… Now now, I know what you’re thinking and this show could have immediately made the mistake of creating a lecherous scenario by having Takuma take advantage of his situation, but right from the get-go not only is Takuma so inexperienced with social interactions that he has to revert to ‘RP’ing’ as Diablo in all his conversations but he is as keen to break the spell as the girls are!

I know that feel, bro.

Why do I have a feeling you’re having an imaginary argument with people who don’t like this show? Because I know they’re out there and I know they’ll take this one element of the show and just run it into the ground. If Takuma/Diablo had been in any way a jerk to these girls or mistreated them I’d have been against him from the get-go, but not only is he understanding of these girls he goes as far as to pledge his allegiance to Rem in order to help her out of her difficult situation?

And what situation is that? She’s got the soul of an ancient and powerful demon lord called Krebskulm inside her that will be released unto the world when she dies.

You know, if I’m not busy…

Oh, so a minor thing then. Why does he help her out? Because he’s a nice guy? Okay, maybe it’s just because he’s treating this like a game and wants to get to the final boss ASAP, but regardless of his true intentions, he ishelping and accepting of Rem in a way that no one has ever been before, he treats her like a person and isn’t afraid of what’s inside her…

Uh-huh, and what’s this about your so-called “nice-guy” protagonist ‘torturing’ her to get the information out of her?! This is why I shouldn’t let you read my notes… *sigh* okay, fine—he does ~kinda~ cross the line by forcing Rem onto the bed and proceeding to stroke then rub and then suck the cat girl’s fuzzy ear in order to get the information out of her. But I’ve seen worse in more positively received series, and even if we’re not comparing, not only is it integral to moving the plot forward but by the end of it nobody is harmed by these ‘shenanigans’… I know, I know it sounds like I’m condoning non-consensual touching here and this is a slippery slope to go down and the last thing I’d want is for people to misconstrue my words as condoning this behaviour in the real world but it’s all about context here!

And what context is that exactly? Aside from what’s explicitly shown on the screen?Let’s not pretend this show isn’t something it’s not, it’s pretty heavy on the fan-service and it’s a comedy driven harem anime—you can judge this against reality as much as you want but the simple fact of the matter is this a fantasy series in more ways than one…

You don’t get this kind of ‘service’ on Crunchyroll.

So it gets a pass because of its genre? I don’t understand what you mean by ‘gets a pass’ it’s in a similar vein to Konosuba, Is It Wrong To Try & Pick Up Girls In A Dungeon and especially No Game No Life—and while those shows have “problematic” elements too it’s never serious enough to derail the show.

But shouldn’t every show, even those shows of very similar genres and types, strive to be better than what’s come before? Maybe this is a horribly reductive thing to say—especially in a day and age where the media we consume can be held up a microscope to us as a society but the only obligation this kind of show has to my mind is to be entertaining.

I mean that’s one way to eat a sausage…

And what about the ways in which its similar to those other ‘isekai’ show, isn’t that a detractor from its overall quality? In some ways it has a lot of derivative elements from those aforementioned series’ but I prefer to think that this show is picking ~just~ enough common elements to create that warm sense of familiarity, while still having its own story to tell and characters to inhabit it. At the end of the day it’s just a whole lot of fun, and while it’s too early to say whether the ‘yet to be introduced’ characters will have as much charm, I’m already won over by this world, it’s inhabitants and the socially inept overpowered protagonist that’s stuck there!

*insert obligatory Megumin reference here*

If you liked my post and want to support my content, please consider supporting my Patreon page, or donating by buying me a coffee on Ko-fi!

patreon

kofi2

Advertisements

15 comments

  1. Hmm… I’m still not convinced that the non-consensual ear scene was justifiable ethically, though it kinda makes sense in context bc our hero is so socially clueless that he has no idea what to do or the implications of what he’s doing. And the three other series you mentioned are better than this one appears to be so far. That being said, I’d largely agree with your assessment, and being a sucker for isekai I’ll probably give this one a chance. 😺

    Liked by 1 person

    1. They may be “better” but Kazuma in Konosuba and Sora in NGNL are both infinitely more familiar with interactions with women, even if it’s fleeting or with his sister (respectively). Here, the show flat out says he’s not so much as interacted with another woman since grade school (except online) and I think that goes a fair way to excuse his actions, but maybe I’m just reaching here…

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Ok, I think I see what you’re saying. I’d still say it’s unethical, but that his guilt or responsibility is lessened given his background. As long as we’re not condoning or justifying violence against women, we’re probably on the same page here.

        Wow, that got surprisingly deep for an isekai harem comedy!

        Liked by 1 person

    2. I thought it was not just socially clueless, but that he actually thought that rubbing her ears would be like rubbing a cat’s ears in his world, which mostly just annoys the cat, but is no big deal. That was my impression of why he picked that, and then it turned out in a way he didn’t expect at all. That is what kind of mitigated some of the ‘torture’ aspect of it, to me.

      Liked by 3 people

  2. Well I think I will pass on this one (nope…I’m pretty sure I WILL pass on this one). But I loved your post for it, and I had to laugh so hard at the caption underneath the first picture. Keep up the great work 😊😊

    Liked by 1 person

  3. I liked this one, it’s certainly better than the most recent submissions in the isekai harem genre, like Smartphone and Death March, which were both one-ep drops. It seemed like, for now, it dealt with the “slavery” bit pretty well, in that the people trying to enslave something were then turned about on it, by someone who really doesn’t want to deal with it. We’ll see if it gets worse, but maybe it won’t. I also liked that it kept it simple and moving along: Nothing super complicated because the writer thought it was “clever”, no giant battles because we have to have that to keep certain people interested.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I suppose at this point the whole “slavery” thing could go either way. I appreciated how well-animated the confrontation at the end was, and it was amusing how one-sided it was while also establishing his power level in this world. I’m happy if the action doesn’t get more complicated than little skirmishes like that.

      Like

  4. After watching the first episode, I was so angry about the push down and the intense focus on Shera’s bouncing-ness that I was ready to drop it.

    The last scene — where he stood up to the self-righteous guards — was kinda cool, but I was ready to drop.

    But I read your post, especially your point that “not only is he understanding of these girls he goes as far as to pledge his allegiance to Rem in order to help her out of her difficult situation?”

    And in these comments, Highway said that maybe Diablo “actually thought that rubbing her ears would be like rubbing a cat’s ears in his world, which mostly just annoys the cat, but is no big deal. ”

    You know what? You’ve convinced me to give it another shot.

    Thanks for a different perspective!

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s